Welcome To Island Fresh Pizza & Subs
Located in Vineyard Haven on Martha's Vineyard, Island Fresh Pizza & Subs is a welcoming stop for relaxed, family-friendly dining. The kitchen brings together a casual island atmosphere with convenient service, making it an easy choice for locals, visitors, and workplace deliveries across the island.
Golden Baked Island Kitchen Experience
Step into a space where warm aromas drift through the air and every creation comes out with a rich, oven-kissed finish. Each bite carries a balance of crisp edges, soft centers, and layered textures that feel comforting yet bold. The kitchen focuses on fresh preparation, generous portions, and a coastal rhythm that makes every visit feel easy, satisfying, and worth coming back for.
Order From Our Website
Skip the wait and place your order directly through our website for quick pickup or delivery. Enjoy a smooth ordering experience designed for convenience, whether you're at home, at work, or exploring Martha's Vineyard. Fresh preparation and timely service make every order simple and reliable.
Captured Fresh From The Oven
Explore a visual collection of freshly prepared creations, warm textures, and inviting island-style presentations.
Ready To Reserve Your Table?
Looking to plan your visit to Island Fresh Pizza & Subs in Vineyard Haven? Reserve your spot ahead of time and enjoy a smooth, relaxed dining experience without the wait. Whether it’s a casual meal with family, a quick stop during your day, or a group gathering, booking in advance helps make your visit easy and comfortable.
Catering Made Easy
Bring freshly prepared island-style meals to your next gathering with catering designed for groups of all sizes. From office lunches to family celebrations, enjoy easy, ready-to-serve options that keep your event organized, smooth, and stress-free while everyone enjoys a warm and satisfying spread.
Visit Us Today!!
Stop by and enjoy a welcoming space with flexible options designed around your day. Choose comfortable dine-in service, quick curbside pickup for on-the-go convenience, or explore thoughtfully prepared vegetarian options available for a lighter choice. However you visit, the experience is kept simple, fresh, and easy to enjoy.
Hours:
Everyday: 11 AM - 9 PM
What our guests are saying
We ordered 2 large pizzas—>> Meat lover’s and traditional pepperoni mushroom. These were by far the best pizzas we’ve had on MV and perhaps even beyond. Thank you, Island Fresh!
Jeremy C.
We’ve been searching for really good pizza on the island for a long time. We now have our fave pizza place. Excellently spiced sauce and terrific New York slyly crust. Terrific!
Lindsey G.
What a gem! They have been here 8 years and we just discovered them this visit. Fantastic pizza and subs! Delicious and fairly priced. Subs were generous and pizza cooked perfectly and toppings were just right! Thin crust was amazing and thick pizza was not too doughy and still crisp. Don't miss out on this hidden gem. Owner is friendly and personable and pricing is extremely fair.
Kathy G.
Featuring
Delivery
Takeout
Curbside Pickup
Catering
Dine In
Reservations
Vegetarian Options
Island Fresh Pizza & Subs Rewards
Join our rewards program, earn points every time you order online, and redeem your points for free food!
Frequently Asked Questions
What are you known for?
We are known for Wings, Mozzarella Sticks, Antipasto Salad, Calzone, Pasta, Garlic Bread, Grilled Chicken Salad, Greek Salad, Salads, and Caesar Salad
Do you offer delivery or takeout?
Yes, we offer Takeout
Where are you located?
We are located in Vineyard Haven, MA at 395 State Rd
What areas do you serve?
We serve the following areas: Tisbury, Oklahoma Heights, Oak Bluffs, Lagoon Heights, Eastville, West Chop, Vineyard Highlands, East Chop, Harthaven, Hartsville, West Tisbury, North Tisbury, Ocean Heights, Jerneganville, Woods Hole, Edgartown, Tississa, Clevelandtown, Quissett.
Our location
